An Open Letter to Franklin Foer

To: Franklin Foer, Editor, The New Republic
From: Timothy, Blogger, Zeal & Activity
CC: Michael Yon, Hugh Hewitt
Re: “Scott Thomas” Affair – Next Steps

Dear Mr. Foer:

Your publication of Army private Scott Thomas Beauchamp’s “Diarist” piece has caused some controversy. Apparently, only one detail of his story – beyond the fact of his existence – has been corroborated. Pvt. Beauchamp appears to have strong political views. He’s not a particularly good writer. It doesn’t help that you knew he is married to one of your staffers.

I suggest that The New Republic run a companion piece in its next issue. It has some similarities with the Beauchamp piece, and some key advantages over it. I am confident that it will meet The New Republic’s standards for freelance writers. Running this piece will provide your readers with a valuable, interesting, and informative contrast with Pvt. Beauchamp’s experience.

Like the Beauchamp piece, it deals with a mass grave – a real one. Again, the grave contained children’s bodies. The atrocity here is far more newsworthy than some cretinous horseplay: the children had been decapitated.

Corroboration will not be a problem. The grave’s excavation was witnessed by at least five American Soldiers from C Company, 1-12 Cavalry, who are identified by name, together with Iraqi soldiers from the 3-25 (5th Division). It was captured on video and in numerous still photographs, and its GPS coordinates are available.

Of course, I’m referring to Michael Yon’s dispatch “Bless the Beasts and Children.” On June 29, in a village about 3.5 miles from Baqubah, the capital of Diyala Province, U.S. and Iraqi troops discovered a mass grave containing the bodies of “10-14” villagers and children, as well as their animals.

Additional detail including a final body count is here and comments from a Diyala provincial council member are here. A video interview with American witnesses is here.

Michael Yon, who has been called “this generation’s Ernie Pyle,” is a former Green Beret and freelance journalist. He has been in Iraq since January 2007 and previously embedded in Mosul with the 1-24 Infantry. He has often criticized U.S. policy in Iraq and Afghanistan and the Army chain of command that authorizes embedded journalists. He was among the first to describe the situation in Iraq as a “civil war.” His writing is powerful, direct, and gripping.

Mr. Yon has offered the “Bless the Beasts and Children” dispatch, photographs, and video to all media outlets free of charge during July 2007. While several news websites and blogs linked to the dispatch, as far as I know, no print publication has carried them. Mr. Yon can be reached at

Publishing Mr. Yon’s dispatch will demonstrate the The New Republic’s commitment to complete coverage of the war in Iraq. It will provide the magazine’s readers with important information about our allies and enemies there. It will showcase a gifted writer with virtually unfettered access to the battlefield. And it will soothe the distracting uproar over Pvt. Beauchamp’s allegations.


CC: Michael Yon, Hugh Hewitt

NOTE: I don’t currently have Mr. Foer’s email address so I haven’t yet sent this letter directly to him. UPDATE: Done, with the help of commenter Sharkman, a little before 9 p.m. GMT on Friday.

UPDATE: Welcome, Hugh Hewitt readers! Have a look around – you might be interested in this somewhat related post on Citizen Journalism.


12 Responses to “An Open Letter to Franklin Foer”

  1. Sharkman Says:


    Then send it to every single listed e-mail on this list (not my website, just found it looking for foer’s e-mail – seems to be everyone who is anyone, as the name implies):

  2. Timothy Says:

    Sharkman – done. Thanks for the pointer. If Mr. Foer agrees, I will post any response here.

  3. HughS Says:

    Well said. Professionally written and documented with appropriate tone. Let’s hope he accepts the offer.

  4. Timothy Says:

    Thanks HughS. I hope so too. I’m not trying to play gotcha; I think TNR would be a good forum for Yon.

  5. MeTooThen Says:

    Well done, Sir.

    But alas.

    And alack.

    Mr. Foer will not take you up on your offer.

    He cannot.

    And will not.

    Not now.

    Not ever.

    As the Truth is said to make one free.

    Mr. Foer, and others of his ilk, will forever be enslaved.


    But a nice try, nonetheless.

    Just sayiin’.

  6. What Have We Learned? The Saga of Pvt. Scott Thomas Beauchamp « Zeal and Activity Says:

    […] Friday, I wrote an open letter to Mr. Foer, suggesting that he publish Michael Yon’s dispatch “Bless the Beasts and […]

  7. Diurceerrothe Says:
    jewelry store management software, software volume discount
    computer software adobe filemaker pro 10 windows torrent
    discount adobe software for office software for linux practicas de coreldraw
    adobe acrobat 9 initial view not saved microsoft web design software
    who sell software filemaker pro 10 basics
    windows vista screen savers filemaker pro v6 troubleshoot

  8. Instant Credit Repair Says:

    You not going to believe this but I have lost all day searching for some articles about this. I wish I knew of this site earlier, it was a fantastic read and really helped me out. Have a good one

  9. Milton Hyde Says:

    If I had a dime for each time I came to… Great read.

  10. Pretty Women : Says:

    Not all diamond jewelry stores are the same so check reviews first before buying on a jewelry store~`’

  11. Glass Coffee Table Says:

    some jewelry stores offer a good deal of bargain for their new jewelry styles :*:

  12. Vanetta Oberholzer Says:

    Along with everything which appears to be developing throughout this area, a significant percentage of viewpoints tend to be fairly exciting. Having said that, I appologize, but I do not give credence to your entire theory, all be it exhilarating none the less. It looks to everyone that your remarks are actually not completely rationalized and in fact you are generally your self not really entirely confident of your assertion. In any event I did take pleasure in reading it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: